Photo: 2025 Deborah Rogers Trophy Winner, North Shore Bombers’ Lucy Yates. September 20, 2025. BISP, Rooty Hill, NSW, Australia. Photo: Narelle Spangher, AFL NSW/ACT
| YEAR | NAME | CLUB |
| 2025 | Lucy Yates | North Shore Bombers |
| 2024 | Caitlin Reid | East Coast Eagles |
| 2023 | Renee Tomkins | East Coast Eagles |
| 2022 | Bryany Parker | East Coast Eagles |
| 2021 | – | – |
| 2020 | Emily Goodsir | Manly Warringah Wolves |
| 2019 | Lisa Steane | Macquarie University |
| 2018 | Sandra Janjetovic | UNSW-ES |
| 2017 | Jasmine Smith | UNSW-ES |
| 2016 | Madeline Collier | UNSW-ES |
| 2015 | Codie Briggs | Newtown Breakaways |
| 2014 | Rachel Stack | Sydney University Bombers |
| 2013 | Jennifer Lew | Sydney University Bombers |
| 2012 | Belinda Pride | Balmain Dockers |