Photo: North Shore’s, Fraser Thurlow – 2025 Rod Podbury Medallist, September 20, 2025. BISP, Rooty Hill, NSW, Australia. Photo: Narelle Spangher, AFL NSW/ACT
| YEAR | NAME | CLUB |
| 2025 | Fraser Thurlow | North Shore Bombers |
| 2024 | Fraser Thurlow | North Shore Bombers |
| 2023 | Kieran Emery | UNSW-ES Bulldogs |
| 2022 | Mitchell CONN | UNSW-ES Bulldogs |
| 2020 | Timothy BARTON | Sydney University |
| 2019 | Errol GULDEN | UNSW Eastern Suburbs |
| 2018 | Justin CANN | UNSW Eastern Suburbs |
| 2017 | Ranga EDIRIWICKRAMA | Pennant Hills |
| 2016 | Kieran EMERY | East Coast Eagles |
| 2015 | Damian DELL’AQUILLA | Pennant Hills |
| 2014 | Anthony ROBERTSON | Manly Warringah |
| 2013 | Lachlan KILPATRICK | Manly Warringah |
| 2012 | Adam GULDEN | UNSW/ES |
| 2011 | Jack DIMERY | East Coast Eagles |
| 2010 | Damien BOWLES | East Coast Eagles |
| 2009 | Gus SEEBECK | East Coast Eagles |
| 2008 | Scott REED | Pennant Hills |
| 2007 | Ryan DAVIS | North Shore |
| 2006 | Kristian PEARSON | East Coast Eagles |
| 2005 | Jarrod CROSBY | North Shore |
| 2004 | Daniel MCPHERSON | North Shore |
| 2003 | David MACGEORGE | UNSW/ES |
| 2002 | David MACGEORGE | UNSW/ES |
| 2001 | Jason BUSH | North Shore |
| 2000 | Barnaby HOWARTH | Pennant Hills |
| 1999 | Trevor BURNETT | Campbelltown |
| 1998 | Andrew HASSETT | Balmain |
| 1997 | Lee CAMPBELL | Balmain |
| 1996 | Chris YARD | Pennant Hills |
| 1995 | Jason UPFILL | Campbelltown |
| 1994 | Shane NICHOLLS | Campbelltown |
| 1993 | Graham JONES | North Shore |
| 1992 | Matthew LLOYD | Sydney Uni |